Generally for rule of thumb I think most forums are fluid. But when I first found these forums about a month ago, I was amazed that they pulled off a fixed design so well. I think it fits the site great.
Generally I like the fixed designs better because I use 3 different computers without my house and they all have different monitor sizes. With fixed witdh, I know where to look ever time.
Hybrid Mode
Forum Contains New Posts 
Forum Contains No New Posts 
Forum is Closed